IMANI Brief – “Ka bi, ma me nka bi” and the Question of Who Gets to Say What, When and How

“I hear the incompetent one says he wants to come back. He wants to come and do more damage. As if he didn’t do enough damage? Well, we are waiting for him.” This unembellished populist declaration made by Vice President H.E Dr. Mahamudu Bawumia in 2018 against H.E President John Dramani Mahama (outgone) stands in stark similarity to the surgical critique President Mahama (as candidate) levelled back at Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo-Addo in 2022, “Your actions as President have totally discredited your self-acquired accolade as a human rights lawyer and activist,” Mahama stated. These words reflect a broader cyclical war of words. They encapsulate an unsettling paradox at the heart of Ghanaian democracy. Political speech is weaponized or protected depending entirely on who is holding the microphone and who commands the machinery of state power.

The traditional Akan philosophy of governance encapsulates democratic expression in the proverb “Ka bi, ma me nka bi,” to wit, “say some, and let me also say some.” This philosophy posits that a healthy society relies on an open marketplace of ideas where no single voice can monopolize truth or authority. In theory, this foundational concept implies an egalitarian space where every citizen possesses an equal right to dissent, critique, and participate. In practice, however, the modern Ghanaian polity operates under a system of selective immunity. The right to be provocative, critical, or controversial is no longer an inherent constitutional right, but rather a luxury item determined by one’s proximity to political power.

Controversy as a luxury good; if only you can afford to be

Freedom of expression has increasingly transformed into a privilege available primarily to those with institutional backing. High-ranking political figures, communication directors, and wealthy party financiers routinely push the absolute boundaries of rhetoric. They issue sweeping accusations, criticize state officials, and flirt with the boundaries of public incitement. Yet, when the state attempts to intervene, entire party apparatuses mobilize, expensive legal networks deploy within minutes, and political considerations often force the state to retreat.

For the average citizen, the reality is entirely different. An ordinary commentator, a local blogger, or an unaligned individual lacks this institutional protective shield. They become the primary targets when law enforcement decides to send a public message. In these scenarios, the legal system does not function as an egalitarian referee, but rather as a system of selective enforcement. If a citizen does not belong to a politically influential class or does not have an opposition party ready to storm a police station on their behalf, a controversial public statement becomes an express ticket to detention.

The rise of digital suppression: muting platforms that give voice to the people

The empirical reality of this speech environment is captured in recent data published by the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA). According to their documentation, the current administration under President John Dramani Mahama has seen an unprecedented acceleration in speech-related detentions. Within the first sixteen months of the administration, the MFWA recorded fourteen separate arrests tied to the publication of false news. Compared to the eight total arrests documented across the entire eight years of the previous administration under Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo-Addo, this represents a staggering nine hundred and fifty percent spike in the rate of speech-related enforcement.

These actions rely on what legal analysts call the twin survival laws of the repealed criminal libel regime. These are Section 208 of the Criminal Offences Act of 1960 and Section 76 of the Electronic Communications Act of 2008. While these provisions were originally designed to protect public order and secure life-saving electronic services, their highly subjective terminology introduces significant risk. Phrasing that penalizes statements causing public fear, alarm, or offensive conduct grants law enforcement immense discretionary power. This open-ended wording makes it remarkably easy to convert civil reputational grievances into criminal state security offenses.

The widening rule of law gap: “not all Ghanaians are equal before the law…”

This statistical reality aligns perfectly with long-term tracking data from the Ghana Center for Democratic Development (CDD-Ghana). Analysing public perception through Afrobarometer surveys reveals a profound structural erosion of belief in the justice system. The data exposes how deeply the public perceives a dual standard of accountability.

In 2008, twenty-eight percent of Ghanaians believed that public officials frequently escaped punishment for crimes, compared to twenty-one percent who felt the same about ordinary citizens, representing a narrow seven-percentage-point difference. By 2022, that gap had expanded dramatically. Seventy-seven percent of citizens believed that powerful officials went unpunished, while the perception regarding ordinary citizens remained stable at twenty-five percent. This massive fifty-two-percentage-point divide serves as empirical proof that the average Ghanaian views the law as a net that catches small fish while letting the big ones break through.

The distortion is equally evident in public evaluations of judicial sentences.

Target Group Too Harsh About Right Too Lenient
Ordinary Citizens 42% 47% 7%
Powerful Officials 6% 28% 68%

While nearly half of the population views punishments for ordinary citizens as fair, almost seven out of ten Ghanaians believe that when powerful figures are actually brought to court, their sentences are entirely too lenient. This pervasive inequality has led to a severe collapse of institutional trust, with the percentage of Ghanaians expressing high trust in the judiciary plummeting from thirty percent down to a mere ten percent over the same period.

Conflating insolence with insurgency; whisking defenceless flies with shovels

This structural imbalance becomes vivid when examining who actually faces the weight of state power. The state routinely confuses moral failures or bad manners with genuine national security threats. This trend transcends political regimes. Under the previous administration, a group of young students from Chiana Senior High School faced severe administrative and state backlash for a viral video containing vulgar insults directed at the sitting president. While their behaviour was undoubtedly insolent, treating student misconduct as a matter of state security reflects an alarming overreach.

The pattern continues with recent crackdowns on digital content creators. In early 2026, the police arrested TikToker Mahama Aminat, known online as Akosua Serwaa Minat, for making threatening remarks against the President in a viral video by invoking the earth and rivers to strike him, and insulting his wife, the First Lady. Similarly, content creator Isaac Boafo, known as Duabo King, was detained for online allegations against Kumasi police officers, and Pastor William Gyimah was arrested after a viral video targeted the Vice President.

When ordinary individuals engage in crude digital outbursts, they are swiftly met with high-handed police operations. Conversely, high-profile politicians often enjoy a different tier of justice. The recurrent legal battles of Kwame Baffoe, popularly known as Abronye DC, illustrate this disparity. Arrested on allegations of offensive conduct and false publication regarding a circuit court judge, Abronye’s legal processing involves national press conferences, massive political debates, and a rapid mobilization of party lawyers that eventually culminates in a standard release on bail. The law is deployed to teach a lesson to the weak, while it negotiates a settlement with the strong.

The psychology of incumbent pleasing; will massa be ’appy?

The root of this persistent problem does not lie solely with individual political leaders, but within the structural architecture of Ghanaian law enforcement. The Inspector General of Police and the heads of national security agencies are direct political appointees of the executive branch. Because their professional survival and career longevity depend entirely on the satisfaction of the sitting president, an institutional incentive structure is created that favours sycophancy.

Security chiefs frequently feel an unwritten pressure to over-perform in demonstrating absolute loyalty. Law enforcement operations are pre-emptively deployed to suppress any voice that might embarrass, insult, or critique the incumbent government. It does not require a direct directive from the presidency to initiate a crackdown. Instead, a hyper-zealous security apparatus acts independently to shield its political patrons from public embarrassment. This dynamic corrupts the neutrality of state security agencies, transforming them into tools for regime protection rather than guardians of civic peace.

Come to think of it…

If democracy is to remain a meaningful framework rather than an empty rhetorical exercise, the foundational principle of equal expression must be restored. The current trajectory warns us that when the law is applied selectively, it ceases to be a tool of justice and becomes an instrument of intimidation.

The promise of equal speech cannot be contingent on political currency or economic wealth. When ordinary citizens observe that their elite counterparts can speak with absolute impunity while they themselves face immediate detention for online insolence, the civic bond fractures. True adherence to our democratic ideals demands that state security agencies step back from policing public manners and focus instead on actual public safety. Until the structural incentives within law enforcement are broken and the twin laws of speech criminalization are reviewed, the egalitarian ideal of letting everyone speak will remain an elite illusion. Ghana must confront this reality before the marketplace of ideas is completely shut down for those who cannot afford the price of admission.

CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF GOVERNANCE ISSUES, May 18-23, 2026

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
WhatsApp

More News/Articles

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest News/Updates in your inbox!