To: H. Kwasi Prempeh (Chairman, CSO Platform on Kelni GVG matters)
From: Franklin Cudjoe (Executive Director, IMANI)
CC: All CSO Platform Members
Date: 21 October 2018
Re: Kelni GVG Contract Lawsuits & Matters Arising
Dear Friends & Partners,
On May 28th, 2018, IMANI’s executives participated in a meeting of the Ghana Anti-Corruption Coalition (GACC) CSO platform members (“CSO Platform”) during which we discussed the contract between the Ministry of Communications and the Ministry of Finance, on one hand, and Kelni GVG, a Haitian-Ghanaian company, on the other hand.
At that time, we decided as partners in the common fight against administrative abuse to solicit more information from the Minister of Communications.
Unfortunately, the Minister refused to treat our correspondence with the necessary seriousness when her office responded on June 11th, 2018, that it could not immediately provide access to the requisite information.
Consequently, a suit was filed at the High Court (human rights division) by Sara Asafo-Adjaye and Maximus Ametorgoh on 11th June 2018 against NCA, the Minister of Communications, the GRA, the Attorney General, the Ghana Chamber of Telecoms, and the four main telecom operators then active in the Ghanaian market. The suit alleged breach of the privacy rights of the plaintiffs and the court was put on notice that a motion for injunctive relief would be filed on 22nd June 2018.
A similar suit was filed at the Supreme Court on 14th June 2018 to pursue the constitutional dimension of the privacy claims on behalf of all potentially affected Ghanaians. The plaintiffs were IMANI and Citizen Ghana, and the defendants this time were the Ministry of Communications and the Attorney General of Ghana.
Another suit was filed by three affiliates of IMANI on the 18th of June 2018 at the High Court against the Ministry of Communications, the Attorney General and Kelni GVG Limited citing breach of the Public Procurement Act (Act 663) and the Public Financial Management Act (Act 921).
On July 3rd, 2018, the High Court ordered the release, by July 9th 2018, of all documents relevant to the matter in the possession of the Ministry of Communications.
The Ministry refused to comply by this deadline. The same court, however, dismissed the application for injunction on July 10th, 2018. Following this development, the only obstacle in the way of the contract became a July 5th injunction secured from the Court of Appeal by Subah Infosolutions in connection with its lawsuit on December 27th, 2017, against the NCA and the GRA for the abrogation of its contract with the two government agencies without the requisite notice.
Sensing an opening, lawyers acting for Kelni GVG made an initial approach to the solicitors acting for the plaintiffs in all three suits, Lexis Praxis, asking to settle the cases out of Court. Naturally IMANI was disinclined to entertain the offer.
However, with the two-month legal holiday imminent, IMANI was anxious about the status of the suits. In various discussions with Lexis Praxis, a picture emerged of serious complications. When the two privacy protection lawsuits were filed, the assumption was that we would have our pick of engineering talent in Ghana to choose from as expert witnesses. Proving that the “real-time” traffic monitoring procedure could not be viable without also endangering private communications required that we establish the concern as one of “capability” not of “intent”.
We needed to show that by virtue of plugging into any other nodes in the live network except those that deliver billing records, the defendants were not merely exceeding their allowances under the Act but were also placing themselves in a position where they could access private communications if they chose to.
For a Court to be swayed by this argument, technical experts with direct knowledge of the systems being deployed were needed. We could not merely present persons with a working knowledge of telecoms in general even though these abounded in our circles.
Unfortunately, despite all our entreaties, no Ghanaian engineer we approached was willing to testify. Virtually all those we could identify work in the various telecom companies or for contractors to those companies and their reticence in testifying against the government’s position appeared to be based on a fear of commercial retribution.
Expert testimony was not relevant to only the two privacy protection suits. A part of our procurement-related suit was also hinged on establishing the abuse of the “restricted tendering” clauses of the Procurement Act by showing rampant misspecification and mismatch of capability between what the process entailed and the kind of companies that were selected to tender.
We had no choice but to look overseas. Our network was helpful in helping us identify a number of highly credible telecom experts that would be willing to testify. These experts would have to fly into Ghana, undergo pre-trial briefing and prepping, and stay put during what could be extensive evidence-in-chief and cross-examination. At least three such experts were required, in billing, signals processing and packet analysis since the domains are substantially different.
When the costs were tallied, IMANI and Lexis Praxis were looking at a bill well over 300,000 GHS, made up of fees, tickets, accommodation bills and contingencies. Lexis Praxis is a new firm with very limited pro bono capacity. IMANI had assured the firm that it will seek the necessary resources to sustain what had become a highly complex legal battle.
IMANI approached Star-Ghana and was duly informed about the intricacies of the grant-making process. Other potential donors also highlighted similar due process requirements. No donor could expedite a grant application considering the sums involved. Finally, a public appeal for resources was made on social media.
By this time the legal vacation was almost over, and a little less than 5% of the required legal support budget seemed likely to be realised. In early September, Lexis Praxis reopened discussions about a potential resolution of the matters through direct negotiations. Whilst the Ministry and the government agencies involved (NCA & GRA) were still unwilling to engage with our concerns, Kelni GVG, understandably, seemed keener. We felt, under the circumstances, that direct negotiations were reasonable and consented to same.
In early October, we were told of the imminent settlement of the lawsuit between Subah and the GRA that would have the effect of lifting the injunction. Meanwhile, we still did not have the necessary resources available to get our witnesses ready and primed to fully pursue the court case.
In light of all these developments, Lexis Praxis advised that the settlement route be considered seriously. Unfortunately, the Ministries and their agencies were not willing to concede on the procurement and public financial management matters. Kelni GVG could only address the technical concerns about potential snooping, and they were willing to allow independent monitoring of an architectural redesign to address the privacy concerns but only if all proceedings in the courts were summarily ended.
Faced with a choice between the potential collapse of all three cases due to resource constraints and the certainty of some progress on one aspect of the dispute, we decided on a strategic manoeuvre of accepting concessions on the privacy issue whilst retaining our right to pursue the procurement matters in other forums. Thus, on 10th October 20118, the three cases were withdrawn completely. There was no court-adopted settlement.
Download The Full Memo
Memo: Kelni GVG Contract Lawsuits & Matters Arising
To: H. Kwasi Prempeh (Chairman, CSO Platform on Kelni GVG matters)
From: Franklin Cudjoe (Executive Director, IMANI)
CC: All CSO Platform Members
Date: 21 October 2018
Re: Kelni GVG Contract Lawsuits & Matters Arising
Dear Friends & Partners,
On May 28th, 2018, IMANI’s executives participated in a meeting of the Ghana Anti-Corruption Coalition (GACC) CSO platform members (“CSO Platform”) during which we discussed the contract between the Ministry of Communications and the Ministry of Finance, on one hand, and Kelni GVG, a Haitian-Ghanaian company, on the other hand.
At that time, we decided as partners in the common fight against administrative abuse to solicit more information from the Minister of Communications.
Unfortunately, the Minister refused to treat our correspondence with the necessary seriousness when her office responded on June 11th, 2018, that it could not immediately provide access to the requisite information.
Consequently, a suit was filed at the High Court (human rights division) by Sara Asafo-Adjaye and Maximus Ametorgoh on 11th June 2018 against NCA, the Minister of Communications, the GRA, the Attorney General, the Ghana Chamber of Telecoms, and the four main telecom operators then active in the Ghanaian market. The suit alleged breach of the privacy rights of the plaintiffs and the court was put on notice that a motion for injunctive relief would be filed on 22nd June 2018.
A similar suit was filed at the Supreme Court on 14th June 2018 to pursue the constitutional dimension of the privacy claims on behalf of all potentially affected Ghanaians. The plaintiffs were IMANI and Citizen Ghana, and the defendants this time were the Ministry of Communications and the Attorney General of Ghana.
Another suit was filed by three affiliates of IMANI on the 18th of June 2018 at the High Court against the Ministry of Communications, the Attorney General and Kelni GVG Limited citing breach of the Public Procurement Act (Act 663) and the Public Financial Management Act (Act 921).
On July 3rd, 2018, the High Court ordered the release, by July 9th 2018, of all documents relevant to the matter in the possession of the Ministry of Communications.
The Ministry refused to comply by this deadline. The same court, however, dismissed the application for injunction on July 10th, 2018. Following this development, the only obstacle in the way of the contract became a July 5th injunction secured from the Court of Appeal by Subah Infosolutions in connection with its lawsuit on December 27th, 2017, against the NCA and the GRA for the abrogation of its contract with the two government agencies without the requisite notice.
Sensing an opening, lawyers acting for Kelni GVG made an initial approach to the solicitors acting for the plaintiffs in all three suits, Lexis Praxis, asking to settle the cases out of Court. Naturally IMANI was disinclined to entertain the offer.
However, with the two-month legal holiday imminent, IMANI was anxious about the status of the suits. In various discussions with Lexis Praxis, a picture emerged of serious complications. When the two privacy protection lawsuits were filed, the assumption was that we would have our pick of engineering talent in Ghana to choose from as expert witnesses. Proving that the “real-time” traffic monitoring procedure could not be viable without also endangering private communications required that we establish the concern as one of “capability” not of “intent”.
We needed to show that by virtue of plugging into any other nodes in the live network except those that deliver billing records, the defendants were not merely exceeding their allowances under the Act but were also placing themselves in a position where they could access private communications if they chose to.
For a Court to be swayed by this argument, technical experts with direct knowledge of the systems being deployed were needed. We could not merely present persons with a working knowledge of telecoms in general even though these abounded in our circles.
Unfortunately, despite all our entreaties, no Ghanaian engineer we approached was willing to testify. Virtually all those we could identify work in the various telecom companies or for contractors to those companies and their reticence in testifying against the government’s position appeared to be based on a fear of commercial retribution.
Expert testimony was not relevant to only the two privacy protection suits. A part of our procurement-related suit was also hinged on establishing the abuse of the “restricted tendering” clauses of the Procurement Act by showing rampant misspecification and mismatch of capability between what the process entailed and the kind of companies that were selected to tender.
We had no choice but to look overseas. Our network was helpful in helping us identify a number of highly credible telecom experts that would be willing to testify. These experts would have to fly into Ghana, undergo pre-trial briefing and prepping, and stay put during what could be extensive evidence-in-chief and cross-examination. At least three such experts were required, in billing, signals processing and packet analysis since the domains are substantially different.
When the costs were tallied, IMANI and Lexis Praxis were looking at a bill well over 300,000 GHS, made up of fees, tickets, accommodation bills and contingencies. Lexis Praxis is a new firm with very limited pro bono capacity. IMANI had assured the firm that it will seek the necessary resources to sustain what had become a highly complex legal battle.
IMANI approached Star-Ghana and was duly informed about the intricacies of the grant-making process. Other potential donors also highlighted similar due process requirements. No donor could expedite a grant application considering the sums involved. Finally, a public appeal for resources was made on social media.
By this time the legal vacation was almost over, and a little less than 5% of the required legal support budget seemed likely to be realised. In early September, Lexis Praxis reopened discussions about a potential resolution of the matters through direct negotiations. Whilst the Ministry and the government agencies involved (NCA & GRA) were still unwilling to engage with our concerns, Kelni GVG, understandably, seemed keener. We felt, under the circumstances, that direct negotiations were reasonable and consented to same.
In early October, we were told of the imminent settlement of the lawsuit between Subah and the GRA that would have the effect of lifting the injunction. Meanwhile, we still did not have the necessary resources available to get our witnesses ready and primed to fully pursue the court case.
In light of all these developments, Lexis Praxis advised that the settlement route be considered seriously. Unfortunately, the Ministries and their agencies were not willing to concede on the procurement and public financial management matters. Kelni GVG could only address the technical concerns about potential snooping, and they were willing to allow independent monitoring of an architectural redesign to address the privacy concerns but only if all proceedings in the courts were summarily ended.
Faced with a choice between the potential collapse of all three cases due to resource constraints and the certainty of some progress on one aspect of the dispute, we decided on a strategic manoeuvre of accepting concessions on the privacy issue whilst retaining our right to pursue the procurement matters in other forums. Thus, on 10th October 20118, the three cases were withdrawn completely. There was no court-adopted settlement.
Download The Full Memo
Related Posts
Independent External Performance Review: Ghana’s Ministry of Transport
Eighty Empty Sheds and a Billion-Cedi Silo Bill
More News/Articles
Ghana on the Move: More than Motion, A Ministry Making Progress
Independent External Performance Review: Ghana’s Ministry of Transport
Eighty Empty Sheds and a Billion-Cedi Silo Bill
Subscribe to our newsletter