On September 22, 2025, Burkina Faso, Mali, and Niger jointly announced their withdrawal from the International Criminal Court (ICC), a move framed as a sovereign assertion against what they described as “selective justice” and “neocolonial interference.” The decision, however, has been widely interpreted as a shield against scrutiny of their own militaries, which stand accused of grave human rights violations. Reports by United Nations experts earlier this year documented summary executions and enforced disappearances in Mali, allegedly carried out by state forces in collaboration with foreign paramilitary groups. Against this backdrop, the promise of establishing a regional human rights court under the Alliance of Sahel States (AES) appears less a bold innovation than an illusory gesture—an institution designed more to deflect international oversight than to deliver justice.
Having withdrawn from the ECOWAS, the credibility of such a court rests on the standards it would adopt. If the AES rejects the Rome Statute and distances itself from the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights, what normative framework would guide its judgments? Without alignment to universal principles, the risk is that accountability becomes selective, serving political expediency rather than the protection of citizens. This tension is captured poignantly in the Akan proverb: “If a naked man promises you a cloth, listen to his name.” The juntas’ pledge to safeguard rights through a court of their own design is undermined by their track record of repression and impunity. Justice, in such a context, is unlikely to emanate from the people; it is more likely to be curated by military leaders seeking legitimacy.
The broader implications extend beyond the Sahel. The withdrawal of these states from the ICC reflects a growing contestation of global governance norms, where sovereignty is invoked to resist external accountability. Yet sovereignty without responsibility risks degenerating into authoritarianism. This is why the African Union (AU) and the United Nations (UN) remain the last institutional bulwarks for citizens caught under repressive, unconstitutional governments. As world leaders debate reforms at the 80th United Nations General Assembly, the same urgency must be directed at the AU. The credibility of both institutions depends on their ability to adapt to new geopolitical realities while safeguarding the rights of ordinary people.
For the AU, reform is not optional. Its Peace and Security Council has too often been paralyzed by political compromise, while its enforcement of the African Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance has been inconsistent. To remain relevant, the AU must strengthen its judicial organs, empower the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights, and ensure that member states comply with its rulings. Equally important is the inclusion of civil society and grassroots voices in continental decision-making, so that the AU speaks not only for governments but for the people they govern. Without such reforms, the AU risks becoming the proverbial naked man—promising cloth it does not possess.
The UN faces parallel challenges. Calls for Security Council reform reflect a recognition that global governance structures remain skewed toward the interests of a few powerful states. Yet reform must go beyond institutional rearrangement to reaffirm the UN’s role as a guarantor of human rights and international law. In regions like the Sahel, where national institutions are compromised, the UN’s monitoring, reporting, and accountability mechanisms are indispensable. The credibility of the international system depends on its willingness to confront abuses, even when committed by governments that invoke sovereignty as a shield.
Ultimately, the question is whether justice in Africa will be defined by the people or by the regimes that govern them. The withdrawal of Burkina Faso, Mali, and Niger from the ICC is a reminder that institutions can be hollowed out when they are stripped of legitimacy and accountability. For both the AU and the UN, the task ahead is to ensure that reform is not cosmetic but transformative—anchored in the principle that sovereignty derives from the people, and that justice must serve them first. Anything less risks leaving citizens unprotected, while leaders weave garments of impunity from the language of independence.
Credit- IMANI’s Criticality Analysis of Governance and Economic Issues September 22–27, 2025


