Confronting Fiscal Irregularities: The 2024 Auditor-General’s Report vs IMANI’s Policy Prescriptions

Ghana’s public finance landscape has been laid bare by two complementary assessments: the Auditor-General’s 2024 annual report, which uncovered GH¢18.4 billion in irregularities across the entire public sector, and IMANI’s third Fiscal Recklessness Index (FRI), which isolated GH¢4.9 billion in discrepancies among Ministries, Departments, and Agencies (MDAs) from 2021–2023. Together, these studies expose deep‐seated weaknesses in revenue reporting, procurement, and internal controls, while also pointing to a coherent reform agenda that aligns empirical audit evidence with targeted policy action.

At the core of the Auditor-General’s findings lies the energy sector, responsible for roughly 86 percent of the 2024 irregularities. Entities under the Ministry of Energy undeclared revenues, withheld taxes, and executed off-system procurements that inflated costs by billions. Of the total, GH¢15.6 billion was classified as recoverable—encompassing debts, misapplied funds, and unremitted levies—while the remaining GH¢2.8 billion arose from procedural breaches in procurement and asset disposal. This breadth of lapses highlights not only the fragility of internal oversight but also a pervasive culture of impunity, given that no institutional heads have been disallowed or surcharged despite clear legal mandates.

IMANI’s FRI, by contrast, zooms in on MDAs alone and employs a mixed-methods methodology to quantify and diagnose fiscal recklessness. Its core findings—a 2.36 percent share of GDP lost to irregularities in 2023, a 90 percent surge in tax infractions, and chronic deficiencies in internal audit functions—echo many of the Auditor-General’s red flags. Notably, the Ministry of Finance recorded the highest FRI score (0.9038), underlining the paradox that the body tasked with safeguarding the treasury has itself been a major source of leakages.

Juxtaposing these two assessments reveals both alignment and critical gaps. The Auditor-General’s spotlight on under-declared revenues in the Electricity Company of Ghana (ECG) and unapproved oil-sector contracts dovetails with IMANI’s call for real-time digitization of tax-compliance enforcement. Likewise, the AG’s recurrent citations of unsupported payments and back-dated agreements mirror FRI’s plea to entrench robust internal audit functions within Ghana’s Integrated Financial Management Information System (GIFMIS). Yet whereas the AG report stops short of prescribing remedies, IMANI’s recommendations sometimes lack the legislative or regulatory heft needed to bind errant actors.

Concrete case studies illustrate this synergy. The AG’s documentation of ECG’s GH¢2.95 billion revenue shortfall finds a direct counterpart in IMANI’s recommendation for automated API links between the Ghana Revenue Authority, ECG, and commercial banks to reconcile tax remittances in real time. Similarly, the Auditor-General’s exposure of multi-million-cedi procurements outside the official e-procurement platform resonates with FRI’s advocacy for mandatory GIFMIS integration for all high-value contracts, coupled with spot checks by the Public Procurement Authority.

Despite these shared diagnoses, residual gaps persist—chiefly around governance and enforcement. The 2025 amendment to the Public Financial Management Act (PFMA) consolidated and repealed the Fiscal Responsibility Act, embedding fiscal rules and establishing an Independent Fiscal Council under one statute. Yet without subsidiary legislation to operationalize the Council’s powers, and absent a transparent disallowance and surcharge record, the political will to punish fiscal miscreants remains tepid. Bridging this enforcement divide is as crucial as tightening technical controls.

An integrated reform roadmap can synchronize audit insights with policy prescriptions. In the short term (6–12 months), activating existing PFM sanctions, publishing a public scorecard on sanction usage, and piloting end-to-end digital procurement in a flagship ministry can yield quick wins. Over the medium term (1–2 years), Parliament should enact the PFMA’s subsidiary regulations to operationalize the Independent Fiscal Council, while the Ministry of Finance and GRA complete nationwide GIFMIS–GRA integration. In the long run (3–5 years), sustained capacity building for internal auditors, interoperability among financial, procurement, and revenue systems, and a culture of continuous compliance will cement both deterrence and accountability.

Converting Ghana’s audit revelations into binding reforms demands coordinated action across the executive, legislature, civil society, and development partners. By aligning the Auditor-General’s 2024 evidence with IMANI’s policy roadmap—and factoring in the 2025 PFMA overhaul—stakeholders can coalesce around a single, actionable plan. Only then can every cedi collected and spent truly serve Ghana’s citizens, restoring fiscal integrity and rebuilding public trust.

Recommendation

Given that GH¢15.6 billion—over 80 percent of the Auditor-General’s 2024 irregularities—are flagged as recoverable, Ghana must pursue a dual enforcement-prevention framework: under the 2025 PFMA amendment, the Ministry of Finance should stand up a dedicated Recovery and Compliance Unit to coordinate forensic audits, issue public disallowance and surcharge notices, and leverage real-time API reconciliation between GIFMIS, the Ghana Revenue Authority, and commercial banks to expedite arrears collection; concurrently, the state should harden its defenses by embedding automated compliance triggers into GIFMIS, institutionalizing surprise spot-checks by the Public Procurement Authority, investing in continuous IPSAS-aligned training for internal auditors, and publishing quarterly compliance scorecards—thereby turning reactive debt recovery into sustained fiscal discipline.

Further Readings

  1. 2024 Auditor General Report uncovers irregularities of GH¢18.4bn, about GH¢9.6bn increase over previous year – MyJoyOnline
  2. Ghana’s energy sector responsible for 86% of 2024 financial irregularities – Auditor-General’s report – MyJoyOnline
  3. Imani and Oxfam Launch Third Fiscal Recklessness Index Report – Imani Africa
  4. Ghana enacts Public Financial Management Act to enhance fiscal discipline
  5. Reforms made by the Public Financial Management (Amendment) Act, 2025 (Act 1136) | Bentsi-Enchill, Letsa & Ankomah.

Credit- IMANI’s Criticality Analysis of Governance and Economic Issues July 20-26, 2025.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
WhatsApp

More News/Articles

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest News/Updates in your inbox!