Once again ignore the aggressive propaganda by the Attorney-General and his spokespersons.
In summary,
- The case on liability succeeded for ENI. The Tribunal ruled that Ghana’s actions breached both Ghanaian law and the Petroleum Agreement. The Minister’s directives were wrong and unlawful.
- The Tribunal agreed with ENI entirely on the conditions for an ‘accumulation’ and that establishing dynamic communication is an essential pre-condition for the MoE to take unitisation measures under Ghanaian law. It found that a straddling accumulation had not been established in any of the reports on which the MoE relied and that the MoE’s powers to order unitisation had therefore not been engaged.
- The October and November Directives were held to have numerous procedural and substantive shortcomings, including that the Minister’s calculation of the tract participation suffered from multiple flaws.
- At this stage, the Tribunal declined to award damages to Eni and Vitol – but the Tribunal noted that “this determination is without prejudice to the Claimants’ right to claim damages if, despite this Award, the wrongful unitisation directives are enforced” (par. 453).
- Ghana’s counterclaim was dismissed and actually laughed out in court. The Attorney-General and his spokespersons aren’t talking about that. Also, he should be bold enough to tell us that had he even won the arbitration, Ghana would have been worse off.
- By the way, did you know that we wouldn’t have been here at all if the government were accommodating of ENI’s overtures to settle amicably even though they had the upper hand? My brother Benjamin Boakye just reminded me that ENI brought their top brass to engage Jubilee twice. They also brought the Prime Minister of Italy to Ghana. But stubbornness and arrogance propelled by local court champions refused to see reason. All they wanted was unitization, even as it did not make economic sense. I even suspect they were rejected based on pure mindless petty Ghanaian politics.
Franklin Cudjoe- Founding President, IMANI Africa


